Book Club Discussion Questions and Guide for The Great Divide by Cristina Henriquez

Book Club Discussion Questions

Print PDF

Please be aware that this discussion guide will contain spoilers!

1. Francisco has raised his son, Omar, since his wife mysteriously disappeared at sea years ago. Despite Francisco's sacrifices, the relationship between them has been difficult. and Francisco disapproves of Omar working on the Panama Canal. How would you describe the different values between father and son? What do you think the Panama Canal represents to each of them?
2. Several characters make the trip to Panama because of work or family obligations or to leave behind a past life. Have you ever had a life event take you somewhere completely unexpected? If you had the chance, would you repeat your decision?
3. explores numerous forces that are integral in shaping the future of Panama—politics, power, community, faith, family, love and more. Which do you think is the most powerful and why?
4. After giving birth to Omar, Esme struggles to recover and eventually disappears with Francisco's boat. In what ways does the reappear throughout the novel? Do you think it's possible to maintain a connection to someone even if they are not present?
5. Valentina has a strong relationship to the town of Gatun, which becomes evident when she considers leaving it behind: "She needed him to understand that Gatun was her. That although she lived in the city, Gatun was the place whose air she had breathed, whose dirt she had walked barefoot upon, whose streets she could follow blindfolded, the place where she had learned how to cook and how to climb and how to argue and how to love, the place that had made her." Have you ever had a particularly strong with a place? What do you think it means to call somewhere home?
6. In the beginning of The Great Divide, Francisco has lost his ability to dream of the world to come. "Perhaps the problem, he thought, was that a person needed faith to be able to see things that did not exist, to imagine a world not yet made." What do you think it takes to believe in the future? What do you think is at stake if we don't?
7. Molly is a minor character, but when she takes photographs at the protest and shows them to an editor at The Canal Record, it leads to one of the most impactful lines in the book. The editor declines to publish the photographs, saying that they are "not right for the Record." What do you think the novel is saying about how history is or is not recorded? Are there other instances in the book that touch on this theme?
8. Miller, disgruntled by his lack of power, takes out his frustration on the men in his charge. To what extent do you believe Miller is responsible when one of them—Berisford—collapses in the Cut and dies?
9. Marian recounts a story about John stopping her from wondering off the path to look at an orchid. Instead, John brings a potted orchid to the house. Marian thinks, "It was always curious to her, though, how a flower like that could look better to John in a pot than it did growing free." For Marian, what is the larger meaning of that statement? Do you think any other characters in the book seek control, like John, or freedom, like Marian?
10. On its surface, The Great Divide refers to the physical divide of the canal itself, but what other divisions, whether physical or metaphorical, are present in the novel?
11. Omar feels that in Ada, he has found someone who understands him. In what ways do Ada's and Omar's situations both mirror and differ from each other? In particular, consider each of their relationships with their families. How much do you need to have in common with someone in order to understand them?

Unless otherwise stated, this discussion guide is reprinted with the permission of Ecco. Any page references refer to a USA edition of the book, usually the trade paperback version, and may vary in other editions.