The Splendid and the Vile: A Saga of Churchill, Family, and Defiance During the Blitz
by Erik Larson
Churchill's Challenging First Year as Prime Minister (1/21/2020)
In this latest book, Larson brings to the fore the skills seen in his previous works; extensive research, a compelling story, and an intimate look at history. He describes the challenges that faced Winston Churchill upon assuming the office of Prime Minister of the U.K. following Neville Chamberlain 's failed appeasement policy and the retreat to Dunkirk. This is early 1940, as France is about to fall to the Nazis – and the foe is turning its awesome military towards the U.K. It is a story told before, but one worth revisiting, about how close Germany came to invading and conquering the U.K. Using extensively researched sources, Larson alternates between the view in London, Berlin and Washington. He adds perspective with details about Churchill's personal life, the lives of his adult children and the people who surrounded him.
While exhaustively researched I found the length and number of details to be challenging. If this had been an academic publication much of the information would probably have been footnoted.
At 500 pages, this is not a quick read but the careful reader will be rewarded. I would recommend this book for any anglophile, devotee of Churchill, WWII history fan, and those who appreciate Larson's ability to make history come alive.
The Romanov Sisters: The Lost Lives of the Daughters of Nicholas and Alexandra
by Helen Rappaport
Intimate and Haunting: The Romanov Mystique (6/7/2014)
Having been fascinated by the Romanov family for a very long time I have read many books about them and this period of Russian history. I was very interested to read "The Romanov Sisters" and gain further insight into Olga, Tatiana, Marie, and Anastasia. Helen Rappaport's book is supported by meticulous research and numerous source documents; she recreates the historical period beautifully. While I very much enjoyed the reading experience and being back in this period of history, I am not sure that I learned anything new or revealing about the sisters. Alexandra's family background and role as a mother was particularly interesting and almost overshadowed the sisters' story at times. As well, Alexei and his illness often took center stage and was distracting. While presenting an historical context is necessary to understanding the Romanov family, I would have liked to have seen more personal information and less focus on the country's difficulties. While the diaries and journals were interesting, the excepts from them were redundant and not very diverse. Sadly, I've come to the conclusion that we may never really know much more about this enigmatic family. As the author reports, almost all the personal writings of the family were destroyed as the revolutionaries swept in and took control. The Romanovs perished over 100 years ago in a country that has since been tumultuous and unbalanced and I wonder if our ability to garner any greater insight into the Romanovs is limited. In short, I liked the book very much as another look at the Romanov family. Whether it provided greater insight into the personal lives of the daughters is dubious.