(1/23/2023)
If you’re tired of mindless thrillers, poorly written stories, books that make you say “meh” The Other Eden is waiting for you. It BLEW me away.
Based on a sad piece of American history, it is the story of a small island off the coast of Maine, inhabited for six generations, a mix of indigenous, Black, and white immigrants living as a community of one, in the 18th and 19th century. However, as the new century is born, so is the idea of eugenics. Thus ends this community.
Author Paul Harding is a master of his craft. The writing is simply sublime, even as it is not my typical favorite style. Long paragraphs, little dialogue, much description and yet, I could not put this short book down. I became invested in the lives of every person living on “Apple Island.” It almost feels like a fairy tale, told out of time, wrenching and heartbreaking, but also inspiring, leaving me awestruck at Harding’s skills.
This book shines a powerful spotlight on humanity’s consistent need to “Other” people who don’t fit into the majority’s opinion of what humans society should contain. This story may break your heart, as it did mine. It may also open our eyes.
We might want to take a lesson from this, as I do not believe history will be kind to what many Americans are doing today to immigrants, refugees, children, and our lgbtqia+ communities. Kindness, compassion, and empathy will make us historical heroes; racism, hatred, and bigotry will find us condemned.