(3/12/2017)
Cliff House, the beloved summer home for three generations of the Young family women, is about to fall into the sea. Erosion is claiming the bluff it stands on in Siasconset, Nantucket Island. Dr. Bess Codman, pregnant and with a crumbling marriage, comes home to convince her mother to move out before the inevitable happens. Cliff House has been home, a place of precious memories, secrets, and solace since her great-grandmother had it built during the Depression years.
As Bess deals with its loss and the ramifications for herself and her mother, the story turns back and forth between the present day and the days of the Second World War, the time of her grandmother, Ruby. Many heartaches and buried family secrets of the past and present are revealed as the novel continues.
Themes of home and homesickness for both time and place, and of family love, secrets, and tragic misunderstandings weave throughout the story. I found the novel a bit hard to get into at first, but it soon hooked me. The characters of Ruby and her family—parents, brother, husband-- are especially well-drawn, and those chapters vividly evoke the era and setting. The tragedies that beset Ruby during wartime are relentless, and her determination to "remain strong" in the face of them makes the book compelling reading. Some of the book's present-day characters are somewhat less compelling, less believable to me, and I found myself getting a bit impatient with them. The conceit of the "Book of Summer," a visitor's book kept at Cliff House for those who stayed there to write in each year, serves to move the narrative forward, however unlikely it seems that people would write such intimate thoughts and feelings in an actual visitor's book in a summer home. In spite of these minor objections, the novel is definitely worth the time spent reading it. An author's note at the back informs us that the book is based upon the "real-life erosion of the Sankaty Bluff in Siasconset--known as Sconset—the easternmost spot on Nantucket Island," the solutions for which are a cause of debate and controversy to the present day.