Catherine House: A Novel
by Elisabeth Thomas
Slow Paced and Unsatisfying (3/16/2020)
This book was touted as a "seductive, gothic-infused debut of literary suspense." I do not agree. I guess you could call it a slow burn when the real mystery part doesn't unfold until you are 30 pages from the end. Every time I thought there was a bit of suspense building up, it would vanish by the next sentence. I can't begin to count the number of times I was left up in the air thinking about abandoning the book.
The main character arrives at an isolated boarding school and from then on, I wondered if it was because she was a zombie. I couldn't tell if she had feelings or didn't have feelings. I think the book would have been improved greatly had the author created a more likable character.
There is something mysterious going on in the school, but we never find out completely what it is. It has something to do with mind control, I guess. The main character sleepwalks through daily life and that's about all the narrative deals with. Every now and then something potentially dramatic happens, but there is no follow through.
And what is a plasm pin anyway?
I think the author has talent and perhaps her next book will be better.
The Splendid and the Vile: A Saga of Churchill, Family, and Defiance During the Blitz
by Erik Larson
Entertaining Light History (2/24/2020)
Winston Churchill was not exaggerating when he said that the future of Western civilization depended upon the outcome of the Battle of Britain. Late 1940 and early 1941 truly was an historic time in the life of the world, and for those wanting or needing a refresher, this book is a good one.
All of the stories in the book have been told before by others and better, but Mr. Larson performs a service by telescoping them into one compact book. The book has its flaws: little is written about the Battle of the Atlantic, the importance of Churchill's speeches is underplayed, and it glosses over some of the major strategic considerations that went into Churchill's decisions, but we learn quite a lot about what life was like in London during the bombing Blitz that Hitler and Goering unleashed on the British Isles in the mistaken belief that the British would crumble and seek a peace deal with the Nazis. Clever use of German propaganda minister Goebbels's diaries also remind us — a useful reminder — of how easily some government officials find it to lie.
Mr. Larson relies mostly on secondary sources, but the ones he uses are reliable. Far more detail is available in any good Churchill biography, but those tend to omit stories about everyday life in London. Knowing what Londoners found to eat, the sexual license of the times, the nights of terror, and the unadulterated courage of the English people provides much needed context. And Larson is, as ever, an entertaining writer.
The Women with Silver Wings: The Inspiring True Story of the Women Airforce Service Pilots of World War II
by Katherine Sharp Landdeck
You Taught Us How to Fly (1/19/2020)
When the United States entered World War II it had been only twenty years since American women were allowed to vote. So perhaps it should come as no surprise that in 1942 the male power structure, especially that of the Army Air Force, believed that women could not fly airplanes.
That was nonsense, of course, as this oral history of the Women Air Force Service Pilots (WASP) aptly demonstrates. It is a well written story of the women who ferried practically every kind of airplane the United States built during the the war all across the country. They were pioneers in the air, but also pioneers in the women's movement and the struggle for equal pay and equal rights which continues.
I wish the book had more historical context. I would have liked to read not only about the women who flew these planes, but also the women who built them, and how women generally fared during the war. It would have been good also to have some information about what happened to women in the military between the sad, unnecessary disbandment of the WASP and U.S. Air Force Major Nicole Malachowski, the first female USAF Thunderbird pilot who addressed these WWII pilots at their last reunion. Hopefully, Dr. Sharp Landdeck will write that book too.
This reviewer assumes the final edition of the book will have an index which the review copy lacked. It needs one.
Women in the United States had come a long way by the time we reach the most moving part of the book. In June 2009 the preeminent American politician of the early 21st Century, the Speaker of the House of Representatives of the United States of America, Nancy Pelosi, said to them, "We are all your daughters; you taught us how to fly."
The Weight of a Piano
by Chris Cander
Good but falls short (12/24/2019)
I wanted to like this book more than I did, so my feelings about it are mixed. 3.5 would be my ideal rating.
I have always wished that antiques (in this case a piano) could talk and tell us their history---where they have lived, who owned them and what they witnessed.
It is 1962 and Katya lives in Russia and is given a Blüthner piano. She becomes a gifted pianist, but when her abusive husband insists that they move to America to better their lives, she is forced to give up her beloved piano.
Fast forward to 2012. Clara lives in California and works as a talented auto mechanic (I never could figure out why the author made her an auto mechanic). Her father gave her the Blüthner for her twelfth birthday. Shortly thereafter her parents die in a house fire. Clara's current relationship is coming to an end and she decides she needs to sell the piano.
It is after this that the stories start to converge and we learn the connections between the characters and the piano.
The narrative alternates back in forth by chapter and by character. (I'm getting really tired of this method of story-telling, but so many authors seem to adopt this technique these days.)The story felt forced and implausible at times and why do authors feel they need to throw in a sex scene or two? (I'm tired of that too.)
There were times when the book was a bit of a thriller and I would get hooked into thinking that it was going to be a page-turner, but that never happened.
Clara was not a terribly likable character and is perhaps one of the reasons the book fell short for me.
And finally I hated the ending.
The Feather Thief: Beauty, Obsession, and the Natural History Heist of the Century
by Kirk Wallace Johnson
Feather Obsessed (7/26/2018)
A fascinating story about a daring theft of rare bird feathers and the obsession behind it. Reads like a whodunit.
My Absolute Darling
by Gabriel Tallent
Didn't live up to the hype (9/15/2017)
I was excited to read this book because of all the buzz about it. The first third of the book was gripping and wonderful, but when I finished it I found that I was furious and disappointed. At the end I wondered: Is this really how a 14 year old behaves and talks, even if raised as a survivalist? Did the author want to impress us with his knowledge of guns that we had to have repeated laborious passages of guns being taken apart, cleaned, put back together? Did the book have to have so much violence in it? Did it have to end the way it did? After I finished it, I kept wondering how the book could have been written to make it live up to the hype. Sadly, I don't recommend this book.