(1/10/2024)
Review of Class, a memoir of motherhood, hunger, and higher education
Land's memoir discloses many students’ economic challenges when balancing college with childcare obligations, debts, and daily life.
She is honest about her struggles. She discloses choices she makes, such as giving precedence to a graduate school application fee over providing her daughter with a better after-school snack.
The vision of a kitchen cupboard with only peanut butter, crackers and juice highlights the daily choices she provides for her daughter while trying to advance her education. This vision humanizes her story.
Her memoir highlights hardships faced by many single parents. The conflicts are intensified by unreliable support from her ex-partner Jamie, societal expectations, and government policies that penalize her for pursuing an education. Reducing her food stamp allowance implies an expectation to take a full-time job, disregarding her efforts to improve her life.
This book searches into Land's struggle for stability and control with numerous challenges. Despite the planning, evidenced by her daybook planner, budgeting, and traversing complex systems, she faces doubt and disorder with unreliable transportation, fluctuating work opportunities, unstable childcare, and temporary personal relationships.
The one obligation Land tried to ignore was the $50,000 in student debt — a liability that would take decades to pay off and could foreclose her purchase of a house, making Land one of America’s “indentured students.”
On the other hand, Land makes choices or displays an attitude that readers see as inappropriate, juvenile, or wrong. Land blames everyone for her problems.
There is an entitlement tone throughout the book. "We deserve” “Victimhood” “Self-pity.” Most of us will have to work throughout our lives, and some jobs will not suit our liking. Yes, we will make bad decisions, and we will pay for those decisions. There are results for everything we do - and do not do.
Land complains about the men in her life, yet she has a child that her ex-boyfriend did not want. Economic troubles follow. She goes on to have another child and does not know who the father is because she has had so many encounters while drinking. More economic problems result.
She complained about all the paperwork involved in welfare, food, daycare, housing, and Medicaid. People are required to demonstrate need. She also objects to her need to be frugal. Many people are in that club.
Land’s behavior appears as that of a teenager. It is surprising to learn she was 35. Where was her good decision-making?
Overall, "CLASS" explores the intersection of poverty, debt, and societal expectations, offering a vivid account of the struggle for financial stability and dignity in the face of overwhelming challenges, along with the personal decisions that create then or results that come from them.
Karen Miller