What do readers think of The Rebellion of Miss Lucy Ann Lobdell by William Klaber? Write your own review.

I enjoyed this book. It is historical fiction but very timely because it deals with a woman disguising herself as man and the consequences of that action. The prejudice and indignities are still familiar. This would be a great book club read. I think those interested in LGBT fiction would like it also. Good read.

Interesting topic depicting the ambitious determination of women seeking more in life than is typically "allowed" or expected. Thoroughly enjoyed it and would recommend it for my book club.

The Rebellion of Miss Lucy Ann Lobdell transported me to a different time. This is not my usual fare - with the transgender subject matter – but the historical time period drew me in and I was pleasantly surprised. After finishing it, I realized that I had read something so powerful, touching and honest. Lucy's story is both heartbreaking and uplifting – her sharp wit and authenticity will make you appreciate every page of this beautiful and accurate portrayal of her struggle to find her place in society.

I read this book in just a couple of days, which means that I liked it. I found myself wanting to know more about Lucy/Joseph's childhood, but the book begins when she's leaving home in her early 20s. There are allusions to past events (a riot Lucy's father was involved in) that are not developed or spelled out, which was frustrating. I found it interesting and a bit frustrating that the author spent a great deal of time describing certain parts of Lucy/Joseph's life, but left out details about other parts.

What a woman! To fight for her individuality like she did was truly inspirational. She was knocked down so many times and came back fighting harder than before. The author did a wonderful job by taking parts of her factual history and making a story that will keep you turning the pages without delay. I had to keep wondering to myself - would of I have been that strong to break out of the normal suppressed life of a woman in that era to live a life that would bring me peace and happiness. A story that was begun to bring a better life for her and her daughter edged more into breaking the rules of society as seen by her peers of that time.

What an interesting story! So many adventures that were closed to a woman that Lucy was able to take. A great read with thoughtful insights both male and female. I am a fan of historical fiction and this book is excellent.

Although I enjoyed this book, and appreciate the research that went into it, I felt from the first page that Lucy Ann Lobdell was destined for a bad end, so I always had a sense of doom or worry hanging over me when I read it. It was enlightening to read how she first decides to "live as a man" to gain better wages and jobs at first, but then comes to realize that "living and dressing as a man" is her true nature. I rejoiced when at times he found acceptance, though very saddened that it was often short lived. He was 100's of years ahead of his time, and I hope, if there is any justice in this world, there is a reincarnated Joseph Lobdell walking around this earth, living life freely, and honestly as he always wanted to, and finally finding acceptance and love. But, rebels take the risk to live what they believe in, because to live a more acceptable life would be a kind of death to them, so one has to admire Lucy/Joseph, and accept his choices.

"The Rebellion of Miss Lucy Ann Lobdell" is, as stated by the author William Klabor, a fictional memoir. Lucy Ann, also known as Joseph, was a real person, born in 1829...a woman and a mother...who lived most of her life as a man. Her father taught her how to shoot and hunt and she became known in her area as the 'female hunter'. In an original memoir, Lucy herself described her life in which she bravely dressed, worked, hunted and married in the guise of a man. Her ability to hunt frequently warded off starvation.

This novel compassionately depicts the many sad, indeed tragic, misfortunes Lucy Ann/Joseph suffered in an era when this type of behavior could not be tolerated. As I read this novel, and realized that Lucy Ann was an actual person and not a figment of Klabor's imagination, I thought of how differently she would have been accepted in today's world. It gives one much to think about and discuss.