What do readers think of He Wanted the Moon by Mimi Baird with Eve Claxton? Write your own review.

I appreciate BookBrowse for giving me the opportunity to read an Arc of He Wanted the Moon. I requested this book because I am bi-polar with psychotic episodes. Mine is controlled with drugs but that unfortunately was not available to Dr. Perry Baird. He suffered terribly with his manic episodes that eventually took everything that mattered to him in his life away from him. A brilliant physician subjected to unbelievable indignities and torture. Being put in a straight jacket and tied to the bed for days. Having freezing bed sheets tightly bound on him for days. Being beaten, given little to eat at times. The …more Doctor in charge seemed to hate the mentally ill and feel that torturing them was how to make them better. But when you were finally let out of this nightmare you had to deal with everyone avoiding you. You had a big mark on you Mentally Ill and there was no getting away from the stigma of that. If I had been born twenty years earlier I would have lived at the State Hospital.

I think this book would be a good read for many people. For history buffs, those interested in mental illness and family dynamics. (less)

Upon starting this small book, the journal of a brilliant bipolar doctor of the 50's, I wondered about the number of people who might be interested. It turned out to be a page turner for me - the doctor's journal and his daughter's narrative of what she knew and when she knew it about her father's life and illness. Terribly sad, but even with a modest interest in mental illness, I was fascinated by his mind and by the way he was treated (I use that word very loosely) by the hospital. When the doctors put him in freezing bedsheets, tighlly bound for days, I was aghast to say the least. Most people will know at …more least one brilliant person who this guy reminds you of, and maybe after reading, you will be sure to treat the victim and his family with the belief that mental illness, just like a physical illness, is no one's fault and there should be no stigma. (less)

Mimi Baird had faint memories of her father and talks of how his disappearance from her life at the age of 6, affected her. When his hand written memoir was unearthed from a briefcase kept by a family member, she was 56. The result was this book, He Wanted the Moon.
This tragic first person telling by a Harvard trained physician, illustrates how a person with a manic disorder in the 1940s suffered loss of family, friends, profession, self esteem and dignity, eventually becoming an outcast from society.

Dr, Baird also writes about his thought processes, giving the reader a clue as to how 'out of control' a person …more with a manic disorder thinks and behaves. While this man was clearly ill, there was almost no help for him.

He Wanted the Moon is heartbreaking to read but it is an important book, for it clearly illustrates the barbaric & cruel treatments patients underwent in the 1940s. I recommend it to everyone, especially to all psychology students. (less)

Personally aware of the devastation to family and friends as well as to the victim of manic depression I had some misgivings about reading this book. However, I was immediately absorbed in the tragic story of the brilliant
Dr Perry Baird. This was a man whose life was stolen by this brutal disease personally and professionally. The ghoulish medical protocol of 1940s mental institutions was barbaric and difficult to read. Dr Baird's struggle for sanity was heartbreaking. It is amazing that so many years later his daughter found his scattered memoirs and was able to piece them together and tell his story in a …more logical and concise format. In doing so she created a spellbinding book as well as answering for herself the reason her father was absent from her life. I would definitely recommend this book (less)

I thoroughly enjoyed this book. I was a psychiatric nurse in the late 1960's at a large University hospital and I was lucky enough to be head nurse on the floor where we did all the Lithium testing for our manic depressive patients. Needless to say the results were extraordinary- especially to see first hand. I so admire Mimi Baird for writing this book about her father and the effect his illness had, not only on his own life but that of his family , friends, and colleagues. She humanized this traumatic illness with its myriad of complications. Dr. Baird was obviously a gifted physician and I am so sad that Dr. …more Baird died before the wonder drug Lithium was released to the public. I would recommend this book to all readers, familiar with manic depression or not. It is a story for all of us. (less)

Wow. What a great read! How hard it must have been to relive her dad's life through his eyes. What an impressive honor to a father, a daughter who wanted to know about her father all her life and had to wait until he was no longer alive. Truly an inspiration.

I feel very fortunate to have received this brilliant book from Bookbrowse. It provides a very unique voice to mental illness and the many ways that it affects the lives of the patient and those around him or her. Mimi Baird brings us her father's manuscript recounting several stages of his mental illness. In it, Dr. Perry Baird illustrates manic depression from the perspective of both patient and physician. He arouses introspection regarding how the mentally ill have been treated and continue to be treated. I found similarities between this book and Susanna Kaysen's "Girl, Interrupted." In that book, the author …more exposes how the handling of the mentally ill at treatment facilities derives from the stigmas and stereotypes that are perpetuated about them. Mimi Baird's book similarly accomplishes this. Additionally, she elucidates how Dr. Perry Baird tried to find a treatment for his own disease. She describes experiments that were abated and went largely ignored for many years due to his mental illness. Her father's brilliant mind shines through despite his mental illness and it is a tragedy that his research was stopped short. Who knows what he could have discovered had he been able to continue his work. The latter part of the book gets into how Mimi's own life was affected by her dad's condition as well as her quest to bring his story to the masses. His story is a very important one, and one that I highly recommend to anyone interested in the examination of mental illness. (less)

This book caught my interest the minute I read the first sentence. So many adult children miss their parents immensely when they pass away, and it is difficult to imagine what this author felt "losing" her father through her mother's rejection of a partner with manic depression and remarriage. There is something very haunting about this book, and I feel like I also learned something about manic depression. The passage on page 89 particularly tugged at my heart: " the father wishing one really didn't know what one was doing. Then one's consciousness would not hold one responsible for what one had done..." I guess …more in my ignorance I thought that people in their manic phase did not remember what they had done. There are many heart wrenching passages, like page 146 where he lay face down in ditches in hide.
At the end of the book I found myself going back to look at the old photograph of the author as a toddler, outside with her smiling father and pet dog. I did not know these people personally, and yet tears came to my eyes as if I did. That is how much this book affected me. (less)