Write your own review!
Dan W. (Fort Myers, FL)
Unexpected Story
When I started reading this book I didn't have a clue as to the subject matter, but I quickly began reading at a fast pace. In fact, after reading about 100 pages, I started reading the book again at a slower pace to better comprehend the details surrounding this event. I was intrigued from the start to the finish of the book as quickly as I could, but maintaining a comprehension of the compelling subject matter.
I have no idea of how the author kept such detailed notes to write such a comprehensive story from start to finish. I only imagine the relief and happiness to the four individuals initially convicted
…more and sent to prison for a crime they were falsely accused of.
It's a credit to the author to write such an elaborate retelling of an hideous event that unjustly sent innocent boys to jail and for it not to be reconciled before they had become men. The author should be credited in writing an award winning book that will capture the interest of its readers! (less)Anyone who believes that our American justice system provides fairness to the disenfranchised among us will find quite a different story here. Writer Brian Patrick O'Donoghue has provided us with a meticulous insider's view of the journalistic equivalent of Sir Ernest Shackleton's Endurance Expedition.
Full of egregious examples of how the legal system let down four young alleged "perpetrators" and the teen-aged victim and their families, this tale should be required reading for every high school graduate. That student participation under O'Donoghue's professorial eye kept the fight for justice going lends much
…more needed inspiration.
The timing of its publishing coincides nicely with an announced damages settlement of $11.5 million for the last of the "Fairbanks Four" victims whose questionable conviction and prolonged incarceration can never be compensated for adequately. (less)Overall I found the book to be extremely interesting and loaded with information. I previously had not heard about this case, even though I consume lots of true crime both in print and in podcasts. One of the things that stands out is that it really points out how witnesses testimony/memories can be very biased and based in what they firmly believe, be it the truth or not, and in the end lead to devastating outcomes. And there are times that these outcomes must be reversed in the name of justice. The road is often very long and difficult.
There were times, however, that I felt the book was a little difficult to
…more follow, especially because chapters were broken down even further, and I would have to go back to reread something to make sense of what I was reading, so that made it take longer to read. There were other times where the author went off on a tangent that would confuse things.
With respect to the factual aspect of the material, it was definitely very thorough from the arrest right up to the overturning of the convictions. Overall, I thought the book was a really good read and would recommend it to any other true crime consumer. (less)As a journalist, Brian Patrick O'Donoghue knew how to track thin threads of evidence to yield a larger picture of the truth. As a teacher at the University of Alaska Fairbanks (UAF), he ignited in his Investigative Reporting students devotion to pursuing the facts. Together, they helped to bring freedom to four young men convicted of murder.
The investigative trail from arrest to release unfolded over several years and involved an ever-larger cast of characters. The students, who changed every semester, propelled the investigation with their varied skills and interests. The detectives were essential characters.
…more Witnesses and family members led the investigating students to still others who might have information. When O'Donoghue and his students interested the Alaska Innocence Project, the story turned and unfolded like a legal thriller, with many lawyers taking center stage. At times, I was tempted to take notes to keep the characters straight. Yet, in the end, I saw that all the characters, both those who inhibited justice and those who pursued it, deserved to be named.
With all the characters and all the information uncovered, the story still moves along at a good pace. O'Donoghue offers a few unnecessary backstories but keeps the reader engaged with the next morsel of information and then the next right to the end of the book.
Taken as a whole, the book offers three interwoven themes. First, the need for equal justice under the law. This is closely tied to a second theme revolving around prejudice. Local Athabascan people testified to slights and injuries replicating those of Blacks or Mexicans in the lower forty-eight. Finally, it takes power to enforce unequal and prejudiced treatment. The powers vested in elected and appointed officials can be augmented by the forces of fear and prejudice present in almost any community.
"The Fairbanks Four: Murder, Injustice, and the Birth of a Movement" isn't just a book about the power applied for unjust ends. It's also a story infused with hope. It reminds us that wherever injustice is found, there can also be people who will work tirelessly and in concert with others to right the scales of justice again. (less)Beginning in 2001, University of Alaska, Fairbanks journalism professor, Brian O'Donoghue enlisted the aid of his students - over several years - to investigate a 1997 murder in which 4 men were convicted - he believed wrongly.
In 2013, the Innocence Project joined in and finally, the convictions were overturned and the men were freed.
It was an interesting idea to involve journalism students - who actually did excellent work in turning up sources and evidence. What was so disheartening was the time it took to unravel what actually happened. To some extent, it shows how difficult it can be to arrive at the truth,
…more but also how when the pressure is on to solve the crime quickly, how easy it can be to railroad someone.
In this case three of the four were Athabascan Indians and the victim was white - which many think contributed to the immediate assumption of guilt and conviction despite lack of clear evidence. What was most troubling was the refusal of the prosecutor to seriously question the methods of achieving confessions, the problem with their star witness and most importantly the insistence that the confession of the actual killer (admitted not only to his lawyer, but also to a prison guard) should not be permitted to be heard. I hadn't realized until reading this that one of the exceptions to lawyer/client confidentiality occurs when an admission reveals that an innocent party has been convicted. And, of course, the admission to the prison guard was not confidential in any case. Yet she still argued for suppression.
The only criticism I have of the book was that there was too much detail. Many of the witnesses interviewed - at length - really had little to nothing to add to finding the truth. It did illustrate how difficult investigations of this sort are, but it was a slog at times to read all of it. Also, while the author was writing about his experience, some of the details of his life - like his trip to India, didn't add much to the story either.
Overall, I would recommend the book as a treatise in how the justice system often does not work without a lot of help from committed investigators. (less)The book is written by a journalist / professor who starts digging into the murder conviction of 4 people found guilty of beating & killing a teenager. The professor (author O'Donoghue) creates an Investigative Reporting course for his students and over several years, they research details of the case. The premise is really interesting and caught my attention.
The execution of the book fell short for me. There were so many names in the book, it was hard to keep track of who was who. Additionally, it felt like a lot of details were not important to the story, but including them caused more confusion.
Sandi W.
The slow wheels of justice...
I wanted to like this book so much more than I did. But I had a real problem following the story. There were so many people in this story I could not keep them straight. It got to the point that I could not even remember the names of the 4 accused - who were the whole point of the book.
A young 14 year old boy was beaten to death in Alaska and soon afterward four boys were arrested - four Native American boys. And therein lays the problem. Half the town were sure those four boys were the correct criminals, the other half opposed to the quick arrest and unsavory police department who arrested them. This story
…more played out for over 18 years before a final solution, showing us just how long it takes the justice system to admit mistakes and then to finally take any corrective action.
The premise of the story was solid, however I had a lot of trouble with how it was written. Not only were so many extra people thrown into the mix, more than once the author threw in a curve ball and just went off on something very unrelated - like the Iditarod. I really find it hard to believe that the author is both a journalist and professor of investigative journalism. Maybe short pieces are his thing, because this book was extremely hard to follow, had way too many unneeded people written in, went on way too long being repetitive and was hard to follow the real crux of the story. (less)This book was engaging from the beginning, and mostly stayed that way. The author's journalistic skills were necessary to tackle a tale that covered so many years and so many people. I did find the wrongly accused It is a tragic story most of us have heard before: jumping to quick and wrong solutions that scapegoat marginalized people, and unrelenting resistance to finding the truth until it could not be stopped. I will not say more about the ending and risk tainting expectations for other.
I found this book too long, which is rare for me. Perhaps the author's very personal and extensive involvement in the
…more search for the truth made editing more difficult. I could follow the legal intricacies and the bureaucratic self-protection in the law enforcement agencies. However, keeping track of the many student co-investigators and other players distracted from staying with the flow of the story.
Over the many years of the story, individuals came and went, and then returned in different roles. If there is a made-for-TV miniseries, that might be a good alternative for many. Including me. (less)
