Book Club Discussion Questions
In a book club? Subscribe to our Book Club Newsletter!
Please be aware that this discussion guide will contain spoilers!
About this Book
Set in Boston in the early years of the twentieth century,
Wickett's Remedy
follows the shifting fortunes of Lydia Kilkenny, who dreams of rising above the
limitations of Southie, the hardscrabble Irish working- class neighborhood where
she was born.
When Lydia takes a job at Gilchrist's department store on Washington Street, she
enters a glittering world that is just across the bridge from Southie, but
worlds away, culturally. Here she meets the shy and refined Henry Wickett, a
medical student from a Boston Brahmin family who falls in love with Lydia's
vibrant enthusiasm. They marry, and Lydia's dreams of a more elegant and
cultured life seem to be coming true. But then Henry announces that he's quit
medical school to create a mail-order patent medicine called Wickett's Remedy, a
kind of placebo accompanied by a consoling letter from Henry for all those whose
illness is, at bottom, loneliness. Before the business can take off, however,
the Spanish Influenza epidemic of 1918 breaks out and claims Henry as one of its
first victims, sending Lydia back home to Southie in a disorienting grief. The
calamity of the epidemic is compounded by America's entrance into World War I.
Lydia's beloved brother Michael joins the fight, leaving her doubly bereft. The
flu begins to ravage Boston, turning the city into a nightmare of fever, panic,
and agonizing death. Impulsively, Lydia volunteers at a hospital that is unable
to keep up with the rising tide of the sick and dying. While caring for others,
she finds a solace for her grief and a higher purpose for her life. The next
day, she answers an ad for a heroic and highly dangerous experimental study to
discover how the flu is transmitted—and how to stop it.
Vividly evoking this tumultuous historical period—through contemporary newspaper
accounts, a chorus of otherworldly commentators, and Goldberg's own masterful
narrative skills—
Wickett's Remedy offers an extended meditation on
sickness and health, memory and imagination, and the dream of progress.
Reader's Guide
- How does Myla Goldberg re-create the city of Boston in the early 1900s?
What descriptive details bring this era to life?
- What role do the ghostly voices in the margins of the text play in
Wickett's Remedy? What kinds of commentary do they offer on the story?
Why has Goldberg added this supernatural layer to her narrative?
- How do the deceased try to communicate with the living in this novel?
How do the living perceive these attempts?
- After one day of volunteering at the hospital, Lydia announces: "I am
meant to be a nurse. I am as sure of this as I have ever been about
anything" [p. 200]. Why has helping the sick been such a compelling and
transformative experience for her? How is her personal history related to
this choice?
- Henry and Lydia are quite different from one another. They come from
vastly different neighborhoods and social classes and are dissimilar
temperamentally and physically. What draws them together? What does each see
in the other? In what ways do they complement each other?
- What do the newspaper articles inserted into the text add to the story?
What do they reveal about the temper of the times?
- How does the story of QD Soda relate to the main narrative? What kind of
man is Quentin Driscoll? Why does he cheat Lydia out of her share of the
profits from QD Soda?
- When Lydia sees Percival Cole's corpse, she thinks: "A corpse was a dead
animal. They were all nothing more than animals, bloated by vanity into
wearing clothes and ascribing lofty purposes to their actions, when in
reality they all died the same dumb death that awaited any overworked
nag—limbs stiff, features frozen in a rictus of shock and pain" [p. 342].
What has brought Lydia to such a despairing view of human beings? Is she
right about human vanity and pretension? In what ways was World War I an
attempt to clothe base instincts in lofty purposes?
- What is the attitude toward the war evinced in the novel? Why are
Michael and his brothers so eager to join the fight?
- In what ways do the characters in Wickett's Remedy and the era in
which they live seem innocent compared to today? How do their views of sex,
love, family, and duty differ from our own? In what ways are they similar?
- What are the pleasures and rewards of reading historical fiction? What
can a fictional narrative of a historical event or period give readers that
a conventional historical account cannot?
- How does Lydia change over the course of the novel? Is she fundamentally
different at the end from how she is at the beginning?
- One of the doctors at Gallup's Island says of Lydia, "The girl doesn't
know how to play bridge. She eats bacon like it's filet mignon. She washes
her clothes by hand rather than send them to the laundry. . . . And that
accent!" [p. 285]. What ethnic and class prejudices are revealed in this
assessment? To what extent is Lydia able to overcome these prejudices?
- What does Wickett's Remedy reveal about early-twentieth-century
ideas of social, scientific, and commercial progress?
Suggested Reading
John M. Barry, The Great Influenza: The Epic Story of the Deadliest Plague in
History; Joan Didion, The Year of Magical Thinking; John Dos Passos,
U.S.A.
Trilogy; Theodore Dreiser, Sister Carrie; George V. Higgins, Cogan's Trade;
Dennis Lehane, A Drink Before the War; Frank McCourt, Angela's Ashes; Edith
Wharton, The House of Mirth.
Page numbers refer to the paperback USA edition and may vary in other editions.
Unless otherwise stated, this discussion guide is reprinted with the permission of Anchor Books.
Any page references refer to a USA edition of the book, usually the trade paperback version, and may vary in other editions.
.png)
