Summary and Reviews of The Swan Thieves by Elizabeth Kostova

Media Reviews

Chicago Tribune Kostova’s new novel is considerably less bloody [than The Historian] but every bit as thought-provoking and suspenseful.

Dallas Morning News Kostova uses words exactly as painters use oils, laying down brushstrokes and tiny layers that at first seem disconnected and abstract, but that eventually coalesce into a glorious whole.

Seattle Times [A]n understated, beautifully written tale of art, love and an obsession triggered by both. The Swan Thieves also shows the same meticulous historical research and scene-setting description that elevated The Historian from a vampire tale to a work of art... While most of the book is set in the modern era, the 19th century passages make it a must read for lovers of historical fiction.

The Washington Post - Donna Rifkind The many ardent admirers of The Historian, Elizabeth Kostova's 2005 first novel, will be happy to learn that her second book offers plenty of the same pleasures... [but] Part of Kostova's point here, unfortunately, is that the human response to nature and art is uniform and unchanging. It's unfortunate because this theme, plotted and peopled over nearly 600 pages, has produced a homogenizing effect: If the dead people here seem reasonably animated, the live characters also seem somewhat deadened, smoothed out, impersonal.

Entertainment Weekly As she demonstrated in The Historian, [Kostova] knows how to craft a breathless ending. But what The Swan Thieves lacks is any maintained sense of urgency. That's a desperate flaw for a story of passion and obsession

The Oregonian Kostova, like Marlow, is clearly intrigued by artistic obsession and passion; what a loss that neither manage to break the surface or offer true insight. There’s a decent 300-page book trapped inside this 564-page tome. And inside that, perhaps, lies the inspiration for a lively screenplay. Even the most successful novelists, as it turns out, need a good editor.

Wall Street Journal [A] soap opera filled with overheated passion and romantic twaddle, much of it preposterous... [Kostova] has worked hard to construct an elaborate fiction of intertwining lives, but the whole situation in which the characters intertwine feels contrived, and they cross as the result of too much coincidence.

The Independent (UK) [F]or all the talk that this is a book about obsession and love, the most disappointing thing about The Swan Thieves is the slightly creepy fact that, within its way too many pages, innocent young women keep falling for the stereotype of the experienced and wise older man, so that in the end it reads more like Woody Allen turning his hand to literary fiction than any serious threat to the writers of the Victorian era which Kostova so clearly cherishes.

The Guardian (UK) As a portrait of a monster with a heavenly gift, the novel is interesting. But it is simply far too long, and rarely achieves real emotional authenticity... Readers expecting the delights of The Historian, beware.

Telegraph (UK) ...The Historian... was a smash hit, a vampire-romp that capered across Europe dragging its breathlessly giggling readers in its wake. The Swan Thieves... will also leave its readers laughing, but for all the wrong reasons.

Library Journal Starred Review. ... sure to be a best seller and a suitable choice for book clubs. Highly recommended.

Publishers Weekly (Signature Review) The Swan Thieves succeeds both in its echoes of The Historian and as it maps new territory for this canny and successful writer.

Kirkus Reviews Neither Robert's decisions nor Marlow's make a lot of sense, but lush prose and abundant drama will render logic beside the point for most readers.

Reader Reviews

Elinor
beautifully painterly
I loved this book from the beginning. The descriptions were so real and I felt the torment of the psychotic artist and the people who loved him. The parallel stories of the 19th and 20th centuries were well done. Janet Elliott
The Swan Theives
I loved this book from the first page; the clever way that it bridged the years, the visual descriptions of people, landscapes and colours. To me it left questions unanswered but this made it even more thought provoking. Even though I finished ...   Read More Patricia Van Es
The swan thieves by Elizabeth Kostova
It is beautifully and sensitively written, the story is not long when you put the whole of it together. One is meant to take your time and enjoy the painters for themselves individually, the scenes they are painting , the human interest and the ...   Read More Heather
Disappointment
Kostiva's first novel held me captivated and spellbound and I was very excited when this second novel came out, however, I couldn't even finish it. The characters were flat, and the storyline just plodded along. I felt as if I was waiting for ...   Read More

Write your own review!

Books with similar themes

• Mystery
  
• Romance/Love Stories
  
• USA
  
• Europe
  
• France
  
• 19th Century
  
• 1980s & '90s
  
• 400+ Pages