Summary and Reviews of Shadowmancer by G.P. Taylor

Media Reviews

Amazon.com - Karin Snelson An apocalyptic battle between good and evil is vigorously, violently fought in British author G.P. Taylor's suspenseful, action-packed fantasy.... a pageturner bursting with magic and myth, and will appeal to fantasy lovers who don't mind the Bible mixed in with their boggles. (Ages 11 and older) 

KLIATT - Michele Winship The traditional religions of early Britain as well as modern divination practices come into Taylor's line of fire. However, his message is clear—evil is always punished and only the faithful will be saved in the end. Ages 12 to 18.

Library Journal With a 250,000-copy first printing and a strong publicity campaign in the works, this British best seller will surely find an American audience. Highly recommended for all collections.

Publishers Weekly Taylor, a vicar himself who is making his writing debut, offers plenty of action, suspense and mystical creatures, all sure to hold appeal for fans of the fantasy genre. Ages 12-up. 

VOYA - Elaine J. O'Quinn This novel is a different kind of fantasy, partly because of the allegorical elements of the Christian faith and partly because the book manages to provide a strong critique of the shortcomings of organized religion, exposing the deception of power and forcing the issue of true faith....The readers of this text will come to it for different reasons—a high compliment to any author. Ages 15 to 18.

Children's Literature - Amie Rose Rotruck Taylor's reliance on telling emotions rather than showing does not help the reader develop a rapport with the characters. Nevertheless, the struggle between good and evil, told in a rather unusual setting in a unique way, makes up quite a bit of ground lost in character development. Ages 12 up.

Kirkus Reviews The Great Adversary makes another bid to overthrow God in this Pullmanesque fantasy, set on the haunted Yorkshire coast. Loaded down with meditations on inner faith, and diatribes against human society (particularly organized religion), this doesn't quite achieve the cosmic sweep for which the author is plainly reaching-but that may come in the sequels. (Fiction. 12-15)

School Library Journal - Bruce Anne Shook Grade 7 Up-The atmospheric Yorkshire coast is the setting for this good versus evil fantasy..... Biblical allusions abound, sometimes bordering on direct quotes. The theme of the triumph of love and light over pure evil reflects the Christian gospel message, with overtones from Paradise Lost. Thomas has dreams or visions of someone who can only be Jesus. Raphah heals a deaf boy and casts out demons. He is also brought back from death. Whether teen readers will understand all this is a matter of conjecture.

Booklist - Jennifer Mattson The characters are either ecstatic believers (It's as if I was blind, and suddenly the blindness is gone), candidates for conversion, or evil adversaries, and although Taylor introduces some deliciously scary demons and monsters, the moments of high drama are merely interruptions in what amounts to a rather ponderous sermon, suffering from characters too overshadowed by pyrotechnical plots and thematic enthusiasms to fully fire the imagination.